Texas- Autonomous sex threatens us all.
Texas argued that the State was “discouraging prurient interests in autonomous sex
and the pursuit of sexual gratification unrelated to procreation and prohibiting
the commercial sale of sex.”
Texans- Do we want our police working to protect procreation? Last time I checked there seemed to be plenty of Texans around. I'm not sure how this law supported procreation. Are Texans choosing not to have children because of sex toys? If so, I don't think we should encourage them to have kids.
I am embarrassed for the lawyer the State sends to defend this idiocy. The prostitution angle was a creative reach by the State. However, it was summarily rejected.
The courts cite the 14th Amendment as the source of an invididuals right to privacy. Privacy rights should come from the 10th Amendment. The language of 10 is clear. However, that line of thinking has never been embraced.
You can't legislate morality. Really, you can't.
The judges also ruled that promoting morality is not a legitimate reason to criminalize activity. From the decision
The State’s primary justifications for the statute are “morality based.”
...These interests in “public morality” cannot constitutionally sustain
the statute after Lawrence.To uphold the statute would be to ignore the
holding in Lawrence and allow the government to burden consensual private
intimate conduct simply by deeming it morally offensive.
The fact that the governing majority in a State has
traditionally viewed a particular practce as immoral is not a sufficient
reason for upholding law prohibiting the practice.
The pace for getting rid of stupid laws is glacially slow. However, any criminal justice resources that were being wasted on "obscene device" prohibition can now be wasted on drug addicts.
Update- The future
I consulted with my appellate expert. He believes this case will be ruled on again by the 5th Circuit "en banc" (where the entire court hears an opinion, as opposed to a 3 judge panel). He also believes that this case will be heard by SCOTUS.